Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571–1610), Death of the Virgin, 1604-1606, Oil on canvas, 369 cm × 245 cm, The Louvre

Completed between 1605 and 1606, the painting is one of the most poignant and controversial depictions of death in the 17th century art, encapsulating the artist’s uncompromising realism and the turbulence of his personal life. Commissioned by Laerzio Cherubini for the church of Santa Maria della Scala in Rome, it was rejected by the Discalced Carmelites, the shoeless Carmelite order, due to its stark realism and perceived lack of decorum. The clergy were scandalised by Caravaggio’s unvarnished portrayal of the Virgin Mary as a lifeless, barefoot woman lying on a simple wooden plank, surrounded by grieving apostles.
The identity of the model for the Virgin has long been debated. Some suggest Caravaggio used the body of Anna Bianchini, a red-haired courtesan who had recently died, as the model. This theory, though never confirmed, stems from Caravaggio’s well-known associations with courtesans, such as Fillide Melandroni, Lena (Maddalena Antognetti), and Anna Bianchini, who had posed for his religious works. His relationships with these women have raised questions about their roles in his life—whether as models, lovers, or something more. However, the model’s identity was not the primary cause of the painting’s rejection.
The Carmelites eventually replaced the work with a more conventional depiction by Carlo Saraceni, who portrayed Mary in an ecstatic ascent to heaven, adhering to the idealised norms of religious art.
At the time of the painting’s creation, Caravaggio’s life was increasingly chaotic. His connections with courtesans like Fillide Melandroni, who was involved with Ranuccio Tomassoni, a notorious pimp, intensified the tensions surrounding him. These conflicts came to a head in 1606 when Caravaggio fatally wounded Tomassoni during a duel. The exact cause of the duel remains unclear, but after Tomassoni’s death, Caravaggio was forced to flee Rome, effectively ending his career in the city and beginning his life in exile.





















